Bekijk volle/desktop versie : Een open brief van een afvallige: "We zijn niet alleen"



Pagina's : [1] 2 3 4

06-06-2010, 15:03



No, I don't believe in God



Alom Shaha, Saturday 5 June 2010 13.00 BST

I'm not grandstanding, or insulting the faith I grew up in. I've written this to confirm to myself that I'm not alone

I am an atheist. I imagine that the typical Cif belief reader may not think this is a particularly big deal, but it is for me, because I'm not just an atheist – I'm an apostate from Islam. Apparently there are people who would happily kill me for making such a statement. But I'm not expecting to be killed, or even threatened; despite what the BNP and certain elements of the press might want you to think, the overwhelming majority of Muslims are not rabid fundamentalists who respond with violence to every perceived slight.

It's not easy "coming out" like this. Yes, this is a term that is usually applied to people declaring their homosexuality, but there are parallels which justify its use in this context – especially if you come from the kind of background I have.

I grew up on a council housing estate in the Elephant and Castle, an area of London notorious for crime and poverty. My family was one of a large wave of Bangladeshi families who emigrated to the UK in the early 1970s. It was a horrid time to be a young Bangladeshi in Britain – a time when pubs displayed signs saying "no Blacks, no Irish, no dogs", and violent racism was rife. We got used to the shouts of "go back home you dirty pakis", and lived in fear of physical abuse ranging from being spat at to being beaten up on the street. In these circumstances, it's not surprising that the Bangladeshi community was a close-knit and insular one.

It was not only our shared experiences as immigrants that unified us, but also our shared religion. Islam was the religion that defined many of my cultural experiences as I was growing up and it is the religion of all those "aunts" and "uncles" who will be so disappointed if they ever read this.

For many of the people I grew up with, being a Bangladeshi is inseparable from being a Muslim. The same is true of many of the Bangladeshi students I teach, as evidenced by a conversation I seem to have at least once a year with new students:

Bangladeshi Student (clearly excited and a little proud at encountering their first Bangladeshi teacher): "Are you from Bangladesh, sir?"

Me: "Yes."

Student: "You must be a Muslim then."

Me: "No, I'm an atheist."

Student (now a little bewildered and visibly disappointed): "But you're from Bangladesh, you must be a Muslim."

I tell my students the truth, but I haven't been so straight with the other Muslims in my life. This is an attempt to fix that. However, this is no dramatic renouncement of Islam, no attack on Islam of the sort the that some people seem to get such a hard-on for. I'm just someone whose education and life experiences have brought me to the conclusion that there probably isn't a god and that I can live a perfectly happy, moral life without practicing any form of religion. Just as people who are gay don't have a choice about it, I don't think I have a choice about being an atheist – I suspect I am somehow predisposed to be a non-believer and am grateful that I've been fortunate enough to live in a country where I can openly express that non-belief.

Once these words are published, there's no turning back for me, there's no more pretending or avoiding the issue with friends and family – some of whom will be hurt and feel insulted by what I write here, some will be disappointed and genuinely concerned that I am sabotaging the future of my eternal soul, and a few will be outraged and disgusted at the thought of having anything to do with an infidel, a kafir. But my oldest, closest friends, the boys I went to primary school with, the boys I still hang out with pretty much every Friday night, the boys I consider brothers, already know I'm an atheist, just as they'd probably have known if I was gay.

It's not for them I've written this piece, it's not for my "uncles" or "aunts" either – in many ways I'd rather they didn't read it. I'd like to say that I've written this as a call to action, to encourage others like me to come out as atheists. But that would be far too grand an ambition. No, the truth is that I've written this for the same reason so many of us tweet or blog these days: to confirm to myself, and to let others know, that we are not alone.

Bron

06-06-2010, 21:16


Mooie brief.

06-06-2010, 21:20
Beetje naive man, maar ik gun hem wel nog een heel lang leven. Al ben ik bang dat hij dat niet zal hebben.

06-06-2010, 21:32

Citaat door SwaffelKing:
niet raar opkijken als kanker binnenkort op de deur klopt


Kijk mam, een deugdzame moslim!

07-06-2010, 10:06


De reacties eronder zijn ook wel interessant om te lezen. Hij reageert zelf ook mee:


Citaat:

Thanks for messages of support. It saddens me that it should take "courage" to be open about one's beliefs.

07-06-2010, 10:15

Citaat door Qirdon:
Mooie brief.


een schitterend brief, zelfs.

07-06-2010, 10:15

Citaat door Chuck_Norris:
Beetje naive man, maar ik gun hem wel nog een heel lang leven. Al ben ik bang dat hij dat niet zal hebben.


ach gossie.. knaagt hij aan je angstbeelden?

07-06-2010, 10:26

Citaat door atropos:
ach gossie.. knaagt hij aan je angstbeelden?


Nee, CHuck moest denken aan dit soort berichten: http://www.haveeru.com.mv/english/details/30855

MALE, May 29, 2010 (HNS) – A Maldivian man was assaulted Friday evening, after he declared his atheist status to the public during the Q&A session of a lecture given by visiting Indian scholar Dr Zakir Naik.

07-06-2010, 10:30

Citaat door Elberfeld:
Nee, CHuck moest denken aan dit soort berichten: http://www.haveeru.com.mv/english/details/30855
MALE, May 29, 2010 (HNS) – A Maldivian man was assaulted Friday evening, after he declared his atheist status to the public during the Q&A session of a lecture given by visiting Indian scholar Dr Zakir Naik.


en londen ligt in de maldiven.

nu snap ik het. dank.

07-06-2010, 10:39

Citaat door atropos:
en londen ligt in de maldiven.

nu snap ik het. dank.


Neu.

In tegenstelling tot op de Malediven is er in Londen nog NOOIT een moslim gesignaleerd die ook maar iets kwaads in de zin had...

07-06-2010, 10:42

Citaat door Elberfeld:
Neu.

In tegenstelling tot op de Malediven is er in Londen nog NOOIT een moslim gesignaleerd die ook maar iets kwaads in de zin had...


ik vind dat je erg weinig respect toont voor wat de briefschrijver te zeggen heeft. het heeft iets van creationisme-aanhangers, dat krampachtige 'barbertje-moet-hangen' geredeneer.

doe eens de falsificatie-methode.

07-06-2010, 10:45

Citaat:
But I'm not expecting to be killed, or even threatened; despite what the BNP and certain elements of the press might want you to think, the overwhelming majority of Muslims are not rabid fundamentalists who respond with violence to every perceived slight.
dit had briefschrijver niet mogen zeggen, vinden sommige prikkers.

07-06-2010, 10:48



Citaat door atropos:
dit had briefschrijver niet mogen zeggen, vinden sommige prikkers.



En waarom niet? Hij kon weleens gelijk hebben.

07-06-2010, 11:09

Citaat door atropos:
ik vind dat je erg weinig respect toont voor wat de briefschrijver te zeggen heeft. het heeft iets van creationisme-aanhangers, dat krampachtige 'barbertje-moet-hangen' geredeneer.

doe eens de falsificatie-methode.




Hoe vaak lezen we op dit forum niet dit soort reacties?

Omdat deze Slaaf van het Westen zich wil inlikken bij zijn Blanke Meesters, verloochent hij zelfs Allah, en wil hij zijn medemoslims van het Ware Geloof afhouden.

En hoewel de Islam een vredelievende godsdienst is, is er maar één passende straf voor aandachttrekkers die luidkeels hun Schepper ontkennen;

"They but wish that ye should reject Faith, as they do, and thus be on the same footing (as they): But take not friends from their ranks until they flee in the way of Allah (From what is forbidden). But if they turn renegades, seize them and slay them wherever ye find them; and (in any case) take no friends or helpers from their ranks” [Koran 4:89].

En Allah weet het het beste

En er hoeft maar één verhitte gek bij te zitten die dit soort onzin echt meent, en de Guardian is weer een briefschrijver armer.

07-06-2010, 11:24

Citaat door Rebel_1963:
En waarom niet? Hij kon weleens gelijk hebben.


omdat het niet strookt met de aanname 'de islam is een gewelddadige religie'.

Pagina's : [1] 2 3 4